I've been thinking a lot over the past months on the subject of penalties for sin and wrongdoing. The event that started me thinking on this subject was when my little sister went to Boot Camp for the Air Force earlier this year. She's the type of person who dislikes confrontation, and would like to remain friends with everyone. So when she was put into a leadership position, and had to recommend penalties for a couple of her subordinates that had messed up, she was nearly in tears. It was the first time in her life that she'd been in a tough situation like this. I wrote her a letter of encouragement, and it grew into the following:
I'd like to present two words to you:
Punishment and
DisciplineWhile these words are often used in english to present the same idea, I'd like to distinguish between the two. The following definitions are from dictionary.com (based on the Random House Dictionary). Emphasis mine.
pun·ish·ment -noun
1. the act of punishing.
2. the fact of being punished, as for an offense or fault.
3. a penalty
inflicted for an offense, fault, etc.
4.
severe handling or treatment.
dis·ci·pline –noun
1.
training to act in accordance with rules; drill: military discipline.
2. activity, exercise, or a regimen that
develops or
improves a skill; training: A daily stint at the typewriter is excellent discipline for a writer.
3. punishment inflicted by way of
correction and
training.
I've cut short the full definition of discipline. Feel free to
Look it up. It continues, much as the portion I posted. You'll notice a big difference between these two definitions. One is all about inflicting a penalty, and the other is about using a penalty to teach, build up, improve and correct.
Before I go further, I want to remind readers that we are to love our neighbors. This means everyone around us. The easy-to-love and those who are not so easy to love. I encourage you to search your heart, and if you find that there is someone you "can't" love, talk to God about it. Ask Him to make your heart like his, because Love is what he has commanded us to do!
Everyone will, at some point, be in a leadership position. As a result, everyone will, at some point, have to consider penalties for the wrongdoing (sin, crime, poor quality work, tardiness, disrespect, etc.) of those under their charge (employees, etc). Now looking at the above definitions, we can do three things: ignore the wrongdoing, punish the offender, or discipline the offender.
If we choose the first, we commit a serious crime. We have failed to make a change. We have failed to help the person improve. We have failed to love.
Ignoring a problem has never solved a problem. Our goal as Christians should be to love our neighbors. That includes our bosses, our subordinates, everyone. Allowing someone to continue doing wrong is not love. It is apathy. If wrong is allowed, it will only continue. Sin hurts us. Sin tears away at the heart and grows like a cancer in the soul. How can we possibly be showing love if we allow another to live in sin?
The second option is to punish the offender. To make sure the wrongdoers know they screwed up. To make them suffer for the things they've done wrong.
Not only is such indignant anger and punishment hurtful to the person it's directed at, but it hurts us as well. A person being punished has no real reason to change. Punishment is merely a sentence that must be carried out. It brings with it no new purpose or motivation, other than to be more sneaky in doing wrong the next time. It hurts us because we were made to love, not to lash out at others for doing wrong. We were made to build up relationships, not to push others down as a result of their sin, something we are all guilty of.
The third option in dealing with wrongdoers is to discipline them. As you'll notice from the above definitions, discipline has connotations of improving, developing, training and correcting.
In some ways it is very similar to punishment. There are still penalties for doing wrong. Sometimes these penalties can be quite severe and painful. The big difference here (and I really want to emphasize this) is that punishment comes as an angry response to sin, while discipline comes from the heart, as a result of love.
Remember again that God has commanded us to love our neighbors. If we truly have love for someone, and see them hurting themselves, should we not do our best to help them? Sin is the biggest self-inflicted hurt there is, and we would be unloving not to try and keep such pain from continuing.
Discipline does imply penalties. But it is done from a heart full of love, with the purpose of building-up, improving life, instructing, and correcting problems. When we discipline, we show that we care about a person enough to not merely look the other way or lash out in anger, but instead to focus on helping that person become a better man or woman.
As a child, my parents always made a point of delaying the penalties of my sins, even if just a few minutes. While I hated spankings, even at a young age I could see a difference between the way my parents spanked me, and the way some other parents went about issuing similar penalties. Rather than lash out in anger, my parents waited to cool down. They then took me aside, explained what I had done wrong, what the penalty was, and then I received the penalties of my wrongs. Afterwards, they made sure to remind me that they love me. I think this is a beautiful example of discipline. Correcting a problem out of love, and a desire to prevent further wrong (pain, damage, etc) in the future.
While the workplace dilemma mentioned earlier might seem to be a very different situation, it's really not. We have a responsibility to discipline others. While a company may do it for their bottom line, worker cohesion, and various other reasons, we should discipline those in our care, being ever mindful of our role as Christians. We are to love one another. Whether in the workplace or in the home, that means correcting sinful situations. We should not merely cause pain to others for their sins, but rather we should discipline with love, in the hopes of changing hearts.
John 13:34 A new commandment I give unto you, That ye love one another; as I have loved you, that ye also love one another.
1 John 4:11 Beloved, if God so loved us, we ought also to love one another.
1 John 4:12 If we love one another, God dwelleth in us, and his love is perfected in us.